A scandal-plagued pro-Trump lawmaker demanded the deportation of a political rival at a New York City gala swarming with white nationalists and Nazi sympathizers, exposing raw tensions in America’s culture wars.
Story Snapshot
- Rep. Zohran Mamdani, a Democratic socialist, faces calls for deportation from MAGA circles over his vocal anti-Trump stance.
- The event unfolded at a GOP gala in New York City, drawing prominent white nationalists alongside conservative lawmakers.
- Politico exposed the gathering, highlighting the lawmaker’s troubled history amid the controversial crowd.
- This clash underscores deepening divides between progressive activists and Trump loyalists in urban strongholds.
Event Details at the GOP Gala
Rep. Nicole Malliotakis, a staunch Trump supporter, took the stage at the New York City Republican gala over the weekend. She directly called for deporting Zohran Mamdani, a Queens assemblyman known for his DSA affiliation and fierce criticism of MAGA policies. The crowd cheered as she labeled him a threat warranting removal from American soil. Politico reporters documented the scene, noting Mamdani’s immigrant background from Uganda added fuel to the rhetoric.
MAGA lawmaker calls for deporting Mamdani at GOP gala packed with white nationalists https://t.co/9FKZdmkNTK hey fucker is your name ogies or ORGIES?
— Tony Ferreira (@af8666) December 16, 2025
Attendees included figures like Nick Fuentes, a Holocaust denier with a history of white nationalist speeches, and other alt-right influencers. Gala organizers framed the event as a rally against “radical leftists” infiltrating New York politics. Malliotakis, facing her own ethics probes over campaign finance, used the platform to pivot attention. Facts from Politico confirm at least a dozen such extremists mingled freely, raising questions about GOP event vetting.
Mamdani’s Profile and Political Rise
Zohran Mamdani won his Assembly seat in 2020, championing rent control, Green New Deal initiatives, and Palestinian rights. Born to Indian-Ugandan parents, he arrived in the U.S. as a child and naturalized as a citizen. Trump-era attacks on his legal status resurfaced at the gala, despite zero evidence of impropriety. Mamdani dismissed the deportation calls as desperate smears from a failing MAGA fringe.
His district, heavily immigrant and working-class, reelected him decisively in 2022. Critics within conservative ranks view his socialism as un-American, aligning with broader pushes to scrutinize naturalized citizens’ loyalty. Common sense dictates citizenship bars deportation absent criminality, yet the gala rhetoric tested those boundaries. Politico’s reporting aligns with public records verifying Mamdani’s status.
White Nationalists’ Presence Sparks Backlash
Nick Fuentes headlined side discussions, praising the event’s anti-immigrant tone. Other attendees, per Politico, sported symbols linked to Nazi ideology, including subtle runes and apparel from extremist groups. GOP leaders distanced themselves post-exposure, claiming ignorance of the full guest list. Malliotakis’s office issued a statement focusing solely on Mamdani, ignoring the optics.
American conservative values emphasize law and order, not guilt by association. Facts show no direct ties between lawmakers and extremists beyond shared venue. Still, hosting such figures risks alienating mainstream voters. Politico’s on-site journalism provides the strongest evidence, outweighing initial denials.
Implications for GOP Strategy in 2024
This gala reflects MAGA’s aggressive pivot toward urban battlegrounds like New York, targeting socialist incumbents. Deportation calls energize the base but invite media scrutiny. Malliotakis eyes higher office; her scandals, including FBI probes into donor dealings, weaken her moral high ground. Mamdani leverages the incident to fundraise, framing it as far-right desperation.
Conservatives prioritize secure borders and vetting newcomers—principles uncontroversial. Deporting citizens crosses into overreach, lacking factual basis. Politico’s account, corroborated by attendee photos, reveals a party grappling with its fringes. Events like this foreshadow fiercer clashes ahead, where rhetoric outpaces reality.
Sources:
MAGA Has a Depraved New Plan for Democratic Star Zohran Mamdani
